Nick Davidson
This Sunday, September 3rd 2017, nearly 11 years and 11 months to the day, a rivalry will be renewed that is steeped and shrouded in history thicker than the fog of the hills of the Appalachian Mountains.
Two land-grant institutions, one founded in 1867, the other in 1872, both standing to serve as beacons of education for the hardworking people of Appalachia.
One nestled along the banks of the Monongahela River, where country roads lead to October nights with the sounds of Mountaineer football ringing through the hills. The other perched adopted the Eastern Continental Divide a mere 250 miles away, rains down the familiar tune of Enter Sandman as the Hokies make their walk into Lane Stadium.
West Virginia and Virginia Tech football are two programs and institutions cut from a more similar cloth than their two fan bases would ever care to admit about one another. Perhaps, just maybe, that’s what makes this rivalry one that is so special. But in order to understand this rivalry, one has to look at the history.
While the two schools started lining up across from each other in 1912, the game didn’t become an annual series until 1957. The Mountaineers dominated the series for the most part until the late 80’s, when the Hokies began to experience a program renaissance under new head coach Frank Beamer.
The 90’s and early 2000’s brought about much more hotly contested games, and in 1997 the rivalry would be given a tangible identity in the form of the Black Diamond Trophy. Virginia Tech has won six of the nine games in which the trophy was on the line, with the most recent being handing the Mountaineers their only defeat of the memorable 2005 Sugar Bowl championship season.
You would probably be hard pressed to come across someone in West Virginia, or the southwestern part of Virginia who doesn’t understand what the term “black diamond” is referencing. However, if you somehow fall into the category that doesn’t, I suggest you pick up a history book and educate yourself on the importance of coal to the region.
The Black Diamond Trophy stands as a symbol of the grit, determination, perseverance and ability to achieve against any and all odds that so often characterizes the personas of these two programs and their supporters. As Virginia Tech left for the ACC, along with an array of elevated hostilities, rumors, accusations and general bad blood spewing between the two programs, the series walked off into the mountains and slumbered its way into a dormant hibernation (at least on the field) standing at 28-22-1 in favor of the Mountaineers.
That all changes on Sunday night at 7:30pm outside of our nation’s capital.
Mountaineers and Hokies alike will circle the wagons, load up the caravans, and fly their battle flags via I-68 traveling east or I-81 traveling north. Make no mistake about it, this is a primetime, top-25 clash, with a New Year’s Six bowl atmosphere on Labor Day Weekend to open the 2017 season.
The banter has gone on all offseason between the two programs, via fans and official team social media alike. It’s time for the talk to end and for the gloves to go on in this heavyweight affair. So without further ado, let’s talk X’s and O’s.
First, we must understand our enemy. Virginia Tech is a team coming off of a 10-4 2016 season being led by second year head coach Justin Fuente. Like it or not, very similarly to the Mountaineers, the Hokies for a long time now have figured out ways to make the most of their personnel and execute at a high level. I don’t expect that to change going into the 2017 season.
Announced recently, the Hokies will be sending out redshirt-freshman quarterback Josh Jackson (no, not the kid that played shooting guard for Kansas and now the Phoenix Suns). The 6’2” Jackson was a 3-star dual-threat quarterback in the 2016 recruiting class according to 247Sports. He brings with him the interesting pedigree of being the son of former University of Michigan offensive coordinator/running backs coach/associate head coach Fred Jackson. Jackson was given the nod to get the start due to his field awareness as well as ball security.
Around Jackson offensively there are a mixture of experienced and new faces. The skill player that the Hokies must lean on heavily for game experience is senior wide receiver Cam Phillips. Phillips brings to the table 2063 career receiving yards, as well as 10 touchdowns. Virginia Tech ended the 2016 season 18th nationally in total offense, two spots behind WVU at 16th. So while there are some new faces at skill positions, they’ll look to keep those steady numbers rolling.
Virginia Tech is of course associated with being a defensive brand of football. Defensive coordinator Bud Foster is the longest tenured coordinator in college football, and his “lunch pail” defenses have been a hallmark of the sport. Many feel that the 2017 version of the Hokies defense could be one of their strongest ever, at least on paper.
In the trenches, the Hokies will enjoy the experience of big men Tim Settle and Ricky Walker holding down the interior, with the likes of Mook Reynolds, Andrew Motuapuaka, and Tremaine Edwards roaming behind them at linebacker. The secondary for the Hokies looks to be strong, but faces some questions as the status of cornerback Brandon Facyson is unknown due to an injury that has raised questions about his status for Sunday.
In short, the Hokies like the Mountaineers are a program that is trending up coming off of a successful 2016 season. They are no slouch, but neither are we. The bottom line is that one of these two good football teams is going to start the season with a loss on Sunday.
Now, onto our beloved Mountaineers. It has been a long time since the bitter end of an otherwise fun 2016 season. The Mountaineers enjoyed a 10-3 season, their best mark since joining the Big 12 in 2012. Head coach Dana Holgorsen and staff without question have settled into Morgantown and look to continue the blue collar business as usual trend of WVU being amongst the winningest programs in college football.
Leading his platoon into battle on Sunday night will be redshirt-junior quarterback Will Grier. If you are reading this article, you most certainly have heard of Grier and have been waiting to see him in live action in a Mountaineer uniform for some time now. Grier was the Parade Magazine Player of the Year, Mr. Football USA, and a four-star composite pro-style quarterback recruit according to 247Sports in 2014.
Grier joining the Mountaineers after transferring from the University of Florida has since sent waves of excitement for his debut. Dana Holgorsen has historically put up big numbers with quarterbacks who were frankly not very highly recruited, so it is intriguing to think what he might do with one of the pedigree of Mr. Grier.
Surrounding Grier on offense the Mountaineers return many familiar faces at the skill positions, along with the return of junior wide receiver David Sills V who is returning from a one-year stint amongst the junior college ranks as a quarterback.
The familiarity and game experience of Ka’Raun White, Gary Jennings and Sills at the starting wide receiver positons should give Grier confidence in getting the ball to these guys. With that being said, the Mountaineers need to identify a reliable second platoon of receivers to provide a valuable rotation to the talented Grier.
In the backfield the Mountaineers will enjoy the return of senior running back and the Big 12’s lead returning rusher Justin Crawford, along with the sophomore duo of Kennedy McKoy and Martell Pettaway. All three of these backs enjoyed at least one 100-yard game last season.
Defensively is where the Mountaineers face without a doubt their most questions. Just like in 2016, the Mountaineers return very few starters and will need to fill those roles with confidence. But just like in 2016, defensive coordinator Tony Gibson has some undeniable talent and experience to plug into those positons to lead his patented DAWGS defense.
Along the defensive line look for a three player anchor of sophomore Reese Donahue, redshirt-senior Xavier Pegues, and redshirt-sophomore Adam Shuler II. Don’t be surprised to see talented freshmen Lamonte McDougle or Darius Stills get some quality game reps, or junior college bigman transfers Jalen Harvey or Ezekiel Rose. The Mountaineers will need them.
At the linebacker positions the stalwart Al-Rasheed Benton will lead the show, along with Xavier Preston, and the emergence of a Mountaineer legacy name promises to make some plays. This coming in the form of redshirt-freshman Dylan Tonkery, younger brother of former Mountaineer defender Wes Tonkery.
The backend of the Mountaineers defense would appear to be its strongest link, with punishing spur Kyzir White being joined by the return of former freshman All-American Dravon Askew-Henry who missed the 2016 season due to injury. At corner there will need to be a success by committee type approach due to the demands of the Big 12’s pass happy nature. Look for Syracuse graduate transfer Corey Winfield, and seasoned veterans like Elijah Battle to make an impact here.
So there it is, my preview for this game on Sunday that is way too long in the making, as well as my quick peek in on what our Mountaineers are bringing to the table for the 2017 season. This rivalry is one that many in the southern part of the state would argue is our biggest. I am looking forward to witnessing this game firsthand at FedEx Field, and I truly believe it’s going to be a great one. Both teams show a lot of promise for the upcoming season, and I honestly can’t say one way or another who is going to come out on top.
With that being said, I don’t think it will take any encouragement to get Mountaineer Nation fired up on Sunday. The mission is simple… bring that Black Diamond Trophy back to where it belongs.